College Admissions · Test-Optional
Usually not, at least not if you want an edge. Most colleges are still test-optional, but a wave of the most selective ones reinstated the SAT and ACT for 2025 and 2026. And where scores stay optional, submitting a strong one still helps. For homeschoolers a score does double duty: it also validates parent-assigned grades.
Technically yes: a test-optional college will read your application without a score and will not penalize you for leaving one out. In practice it is more complicated. A strong score is still a positive factor, and when a score is missing, admissions officers often infer that it would not have helped. The Wall Street Journal has reported that applicants who left scores out tended to look less competitive across other measures too.
So "optional" is better understood as "you choose whether to add this piece of evidence," not "this evidence does not count." At a selective college, choosing not to add a data point in a fierce competition is rarely neutral.
The pandemic pushed most colleges test-optional in 2020. Since 2024 the most selective ones have been reversing course, which is the clearest signal yet that scores still carry weight where competition is highest.
Reinstating a testing requirement for the 2025-2026 cycle are Harvard, Yale, Brown, Dartmouth, MIT, Caltech, Georgetown, and the University of Texas at Austin, along with the entire Florida and Georgia public university systems. Others, including Stanford, the University of Pennsylvania, Cornell, Carnegie Mellon, and Johns Hopkins, are phasing requirements back in for the class of 2030, and Princeton for the 2027-2028 cycle.
At the same time, by industry estimates around 80% of four-year colleges remain test-optional or test-blind for 2025-2026. So the headline is not "testing is back everywhere." It is that testing came back exactly where admission is hardest, while most schools still let you decide. Source: College Transitions.
The deciding number is the college's middle-50% range, the scores its middle half of admitted students earned, published in its Common Data Set and on most admissions pages.
| Situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| Score is at or above the college's middle-50% | Submit. It is a clear positive. |
| Score is near the bottom of the range | Usually submit, especially as a homeschooler, since it still corroborates your transcript. |
| Score is well below the range | Weigh it carefully. A far-below-range score can hurt more than a missing one. |
| College is fully test-blind | Do not submit. It will not be read either way. |
Do not read "optional" as a reason to skip the test. If you never sit for the SAT or ACT, you remove a lever you might have wanted at your reach schools, and you give up the one piece of outside evidence that a homeschool application leans on most.
For a homeschooler the math tilts further toward submitting, because a score is not just an achievement, it is verification. A homeschool transcript is written by a parent, typically without accreditation or class rank, so admissions officers look for outside evidence that the grades are real. A test score is the most standardized piece of that evidence.
This is the same reason grades and test scores need to be consistent: the score is what makes the transcript believable. Skip the test, and you hand a selective college a parent-graded record with nothing external to back it up.
Treat the SAT or ACT as part of the transcript project, not a separate errand. A score in or above a college's range turns a self-reported GPA into a credible one, and it is the fastest way to answer the quiet question every admissions officer has about a homeschool file: can I trust these grades?
Yes in the narrow sense that you will not be penalized for leaving a score out, but a strong score is still a positive factor, and a missing score is often read as a weak one. At selective colleges, submitting good scores is close to expected even when it is not required.
Not automatically, and it is the right call when a score is well below a college's range. But if your score is at or above the middle-50% range, withholding it removes a clear advantage, and colleges tend to assume an unsubmitted score would have been low.
For 2025-2026, schools including Harvard, Yale, Brown, Dartmouth, MIT, Caltech, Georgetown, and UT Austin, plus the Florida and Georgia public university systems, require testing again. Stanford, Penn, Cornell, Carnegie Mellon, and Johns Hopkins phase it back in for the class of 2030, and Princeton for 2027-2028. Around 80% of four-year colleges still remain test-optional or test-blind.
Usually yes. A homeschool transcript is parent-assigned and typically unaccredited, so a standardized score is the outside evidence that verifies the grades. Submit when your score is at or above a college's range, and take the test even when a college is test-optional so the option exists.
A clean, professional, college-ready transcript with automatic weighted and unweighted GPA. The on-screen build is free to start.
Start Free